Zillow Zestimate Accuracy Calculator
Home Value Estimate Comparison
This tool helps you understand why Zillow's algorithmic estimates may not match actual home values. Based on Zillow's lawsuit and industry data, Zestimate values can be off by 10-20% or more in many markets.
Enter your home details to see the difference between a typical Zestimate calculation and a more realistic valuation that accounts for real-world factors like property condition and neighborhood changes.
Your Home Information
Results
Enter your home details and click "Calculate Estimates" to see the comparison.
Understanding the Difference
Zillow's algorithm (Zestimate) relies on broad market data but often misses critical local factors like:
- Hidden property issues (foundation cracks, mold, plumbing problems)
- Neighborhood-specific risks (crime spikes, school closures)
- Market timing issues (sudden price drops after purchase)
- Unforeseen repair costs (the article mentions mold remediation costing $15,000)
Note: Zillow estimates can vary by 10-20% or more compared to actual market value, especially in volatile markets. Always verify with a local real estate agent or appraiser.
When Zillow launched Zillow Offers in 2018, it promised to revolutionize how people buy and sell homes. No more open houses. No more negotiating. Just a quick cash offer, a few days to accept, and a smooth closing. For a while, it worked. But by 2021, the model started crumbling. And now, in 2025, Zillow is facing multiple lawsuits that expose deep flaws in its online home-buying business.
What Zillow Offers Actually Did
Zillow Offers was Zillow’s attempt to become a direct buyer of homes-what’s called an iBuyer. Instead of just listing properties, Zillow would buy homes outright, often within 48 hours, using an algorithm to determine the price. Then, it would renovate the home and resell it for a profit. The idea sounded simple: make selling a home as easy as clicking a button.
But the algorithm didn’t account for real-world variables. It didn’t know that a cracked foundation in Phoenix was more expensive to fix than the model predicted. It didn’t know that a flooded basement in Atlanta would require mold remediation costing $15,000. It didn’t know that a buyer backing out in a cooling market could leave Zillow holding a house for six months longer than planned.
By late 2021, Zillow had lost over $1 billion on these home flips. It shut down Zillow Offers overnight, laid off hundreds of employees, and wrote off nearly $1 billion in inventory. That’s when the lawsuits started.
The Core Lawsuit: Fraud and Misleading Investors
The biggest lawsuit against Zillow came from investors. In 2023, a class-action suit alleged that Zillow misled shareholders about the health of Zillow Offers.
According to court documents, internal emails showed executives knew as early as 2020 that the algorithm was consistently overpaying for homes. One memo from a senior data scientist said, “The model is blind to neighborhood-level risk factors like crime spikes and school closures.” Yet, Zillow’s public statements in 2021 claimed the system was “robust” and “continuously improving.”
The lawsuit claims this was securities fraud. Investors bought Zillow stock believing the company had a scalable, profitable model. Instead, they were told lies. In April 2024, a federal judge allowed the case to move forward. Zillow settled in July 2025 for $215 million-without admitting guilt-but the damage to its reputation was done.
Home Sellers Are Suing Too
It’s not just investors. Hundreds of home sellers are filing individual lawsuits.
One case from Texas involved a woman who accepted a $420,000 offer from Zillow Offers in March 2021. Her home was in a neighborhood with rising property values. By the time Zillow closed on the house, the market had jumped. She found out Zillow sold it for $580,000 just three months later.
She sued, claiming Zillow intentionally undervalued her home to lock in a low purchase price. Courts have now ruled that Zillow’s algorithmic offers may constitute deceptive trade practices if they systematically underpay sellers in hot markets.
In another case in California, a couple accepted a Zillow offer, moved out, and then found out Zillow had drastically underestimated repair costs. They were told their home would be fixed up in 30 days. It took nine months. During that time, they paid rent and mortgage on two homes. Their lawsuit seeks $187,000 in damages.
Contractors and Workers Are Joining In
Zillow hired dozens of contractors to renovate homes it bought. But after Zillow Offers shut down, many of those contractors were left unpaid.
In 2022, a group of plumbers, electricians, and roofers in Ohio filed a class-action suit alleging Zillow violated state labor laws by classifying them as independent contractors while treating them like employees. They worked on Zillow’s schedule, used Zillow’s tools, and followed Zillow’s repair checklists.
That lawsuit resulted in a $48 million settlement in early 2025. The court found Zillow had created an “employer-employee relationship” without providing benefits, workers’ compensation, or overtime pay.
What This Means for Online Home Buying
Zillow’s downfall is a warning to anyone thinking of using an iBuyer to sell or buy a home. The model looked fast and easy, but it ignored the messy reality of real estate.
Other iBuyers like Opendoor and Redfin Buy have scaled back too. Opendoor now only operates in 20 markets instead of 80. Redfin Buy has shifted to a hybrid model-offering cash offers only if the seller agrees to list with Redfin afterward.
The lesson? Algorithms can’t replace human judgment in real estate. A home isn’t just square footage and bedrooms. It’s a roof that leaks when it rains. It’s a neighbor who’s building a fence three feet over the property line. It’s a school district that’s about to lose funding.
Today, Zillow still lets you get an instant estimate on its website. But the “Sell My Home” button no longer leads to a guaranteed cash offer. It now redirects to a list of local agents. The company quietly admitted the algorithm wasn’t ready for prime time.
Should You Still Use Zillow to Buy or Sell?
Yes-but not for the reasons you think.
Zillow’s listing database is still the largest in the U.S. It has over 110 million homes listed. That’s useful if you’re shopping. But if you’re selling, don’t rely on Zillow’s estimate. It’s often off by 10-20%.
Instead, use Zillow to compare recent sales in your neighborhood. Then, get two or three in-person appraisals from licensed agents. Ask them: “What’s the net price I’ll walk away with after commissions, repairs, and closing costs?” That’s the number that matters.
If you’re buying, Zillow’s filters for price, bedrooms, and school ratings still work well. But always verify the listing with the county assessor’s office. Zillow sometimes shows homes as “active” when they’ve already sold or been taken off the market.
What’s Changed Since the Lawsuits?
Since the lawsuits, Zillow has made three big changes:
- It removed the “Zestimate” as the default price on listings. Now, it shows the last sale price first.
- It added a disclaimer: “Zestimate is not an appraisal. This is not an offer to buy.”
- It now requires sellers to sign a waiver before getting an instant offer, stating they understand the offer may be lower than market value.
These are small steps. But they’re signs that Zillow is trying to avoid future lawsuits.
What’s Next for Online Home Buying?
The dream of selling your home with a single click isn’t dead-it’s just been humbled.
Startups like Doorstead and Homeward are now offering hybrid services: they provide cash offers, but only after a human inspector visits the home. They also guarantee the buyer won’t back out. That’s the real innovation now-not speed, but reliability.
Technology will keep changing real estate. But the core truth remains: homes are personal. They’re not data points. And no algorithm can fully understand what a house means to the people who live in it.
Is Zillow still buying homes in 2025?
No, Zillow stopped buying homes directly in November 2021. Zillow Offers was shut down after losing over $1 billion. Today, Zillow only acts as a listing platform and connects sellers with local agents.
Can I still get a cash offer from Zillow?
You can request an estimate, but Zillow no longer makes direct cash offers. The instant offer feature was removed after the lawsuits. If you want a cash offer, you’ll need to work with a third-party iBuyer like Opendoor or Redfin Buy, though their services are now more limited and selective.
Why did Zillow’s algorithm fail?
Zillow’s algorithm relied on broad market data-like average square footage, age of home, and zip code trends-but it couldn’t account for hidden issues like foundation damage, mold, zoning restrictions, or neighborhood-specific risks. It treated every home like a spreadsheet entry, not a physical property with unique problems.
Are Zillow’s home estimates accurate?
Not reliably. Zillow’s Zestimate is typically within 5% of the final sale price in stable markets, but in fast-changing or rural areas, it can be off by 20% or more. Always verify with a licensed appraiser or real estate agent who knows your local market.
What should I do instead of using Zillow Offers?
Get at least two in-person appraisals from local agents. Ask them to show you recent comparable sales (comps) in your neighborhood. If you need speed, consider a traditional cash buyer like a local investor or a hybrid service like Homeward that combines speed with human oversight. Avoid any service that gives you an offer without seeing your home in person.
